Paris Police Chief Sparks Outcry by Advising Shopkeepers to Hire Private Security Ahead of Saturday’s Far-Left Protests

55 minutes ago 34

PARIS—Shop owners in Paris are bracing for a new weekend of far-left protests against the rising cost of living, after last week’s demonstrations devolved into violence, looting, and arson across France.

In the capital, 451 shops were vandalized on Oct. 17 and 18, including 228 that were looted, according to the City of Paris. The government counts about 3,000 businesses hit nationwide.

On Oct. 22, nearly every store along the Champs-Élysées was barricading its storefront with metal shutters, security grilles, or wooden boards, as bewildered tourists looked on, The Epoch Times observed. Chanel, Lacoste, and Louis Vuitton all had been targeted by looters last week.

Near the Place de la République, workers have been screwing plywood panels over windows and doors, while posters on the boards invite residents to join a neighborhood WhatsApp group against break-ins.

Shops were not the only targets on Oct. 17. In Paris, individuals also forced their way into residential buildings, The Epoch Times witnessed.

Hire Private Security Agents

In a letter sent on Oct. 21 to Paris’s local elected officials, reported by France Info, Police Prefect Patrice Faure urged shop owners near the protest routes to hire private security agents, “possibly with dog-handler teams,” lower their shutters, and consider not opening on Saturday.

The reinforced police deployment cannot on its own guarantee the protection of every establishment, the letter states.

The advice sparked outcry from critics who said protecting citizens is the state’s job, not shopkeepers’.

“The government is asking shopkeepers to pay for private security guards out of their own pockets. This is an admission that it can no longer fulfill its most fundamental duty: protecting the French people,” Sarah Knafo, a member of the European Parliament and one of the leading figures of the conservative Reconquest party, said on X.

“In return,” she said, “can shopkeepers stop paying taxes to the government?”

The boutique of French luxury brand Guerlain on the Champs-Élysées in Paris is secured with a metal shutter and wooden panels ahead of far-left protests planned for Oc. 24 on Oct. 22, 2026. (Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times)

The boutique of French luxury brand Guerlain on the Champs-Élysées in Paris is secured with a metal shutter and wooden panels ahead of far-left protests planned for Oc. 24 on Oct. 22, 2026. Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times

David Lisnard, the president of New Energy, wrote on X that this is “an unacceptable admission of powerlessness and a complete reversal of fundamental principles.”

“Shopkeepers pay for the repairs, pay taxes so that the state ensures their security, and are now expected to pay a third time for private security,” he said.

Faure later conceded a “clumsiness” in his wording, while stating that protecting shop owners remained the authorities’ responsibility and priority.

The boutique of French luxury brand Louis Vuitton is protected by metal barriers ahead of far-left protests planned for Oct. 24 on Avenue George V, next to the avenue of the Champs-Élysées in Paris, on Oct. 22, 2026. (Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times)

The boutique of French luxury brand Louis Vuitton is protected by metal barriers ahead of far-left protests planned for Oct. 24 on Avenue George V, next to the avenue of the Champs-Élysées in Paris, on Oct. 22, 2026. Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times

Unarmed and Outnumbered

Requests for quotes have doubled since the riots, according to the French Union of Security Professions, the industry federation.

“Calls to our switchboard and email requests have multiplied,” Raphaël Mashhadi, manager of the Paris firm Gardiennage Paris RMS, told The Epoch Times.

Clothing boutiques, grocery stores, and hotels are booking guards in advance “on top of physical protections such as wooden panels,” he said.

A 12-hour night shift costs 420 euros (about $470) before tax, Mashhadi said, against the 10,000 to 20,000 euros he said a smashed storefront window can cost.

“The difference speaks for itself,” he said.

Cyril Baudouin, who runs RPro Sécurité, told The Epoch Times that his activity had risen by 5 percent to 15 percent and that he would turn down requests he could not staff. He called the appeal “a bit unfortunate” for shop owners who already suffered losses and must now pay for their own protection.

“It might have been preferable for the state to pay for the service, or to requisition private security companies, since prefects have the power to do so,” Baudouin said.

Under French law, security guards are normally confined to the premises they are hired to protect, and they can only carry a weapon when lives are considered to be at “exceptional risk,” and even then only with the prefect’s sign-off for each individual assignment.

“We cannot be armed the way police officers and gendarmes are,” Mashhadi said.

Baudouin said a prefectoral order could at least have allowed agents to carry pepper gel on the street during the protest.

“A security agent alone can do nothing. What we saw was not even a crowd; it was a horde of rioters, violent people, and there were many of them,” Baudouin said.

The boutique of French clothing brand Lacoste is protected by metal fencing ahead of protests planned for Oct. 24 on the Champs-Élysées in Paris on Oct. 22, 2026. (Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times)

The boutique of French clothing brand Lacoste is protected by metal fencing ahead of protests planned for Oct. 24 on the Champs-Élysées in Paris on Oct. 22, 2026. Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times

The only option is to evacuate staff, lock up, and call the police, he said, stressing that guards may block a doorway but can’t strike anyone, as a single complaint can cost them their license.

“We are there to prevent, deter, alert, and assist.”

‘They Are Arming Themselves’

While some have turned to private security firms, others are taking matters into their own hands, enlisting friends and relatives to watch over their stores or, in some cases, arming themselves.

Gun shop orders have risen tenfold since the looting, according to Yves Gollety, a Paris gunsmith who heads the national gunsmiths’ association, who told AFP buyers were “essentially shop owners and restaurateurs completely traumatized by what happened.” Rubber-ball launchers, tear-gas canisters, and telescopic batons are selling out.

An Elabe poll for BFMTV found that 61 percent of French people believe they will have to ensure their own safety because the police “no longer manage to protect the population,” and half fear for their safety or belongings.

A boarded-up window, shattered glass, and “Tax the Rich” graffiti are seen outside the boutique of French luxury brand Kenzo on Boulevard de la Madeleine in Paris on Oct. 18, 2026. (Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times)

A boarded-up window, shattered glass, and “Tax the Rich” graffiti are seen outside the boutique of French luxury brand Kenzo on Boulevard de la Madeleine in Paris on Oct. 18, 2026. Etienne Fauchaire/The Epoch Times

Macron Acknowledges ‘Failures of Anticipation’

On Oct. 22, after convening the intelligence services at the Élysée, Macron acknowledged “failures of anticipation” and “elements of surprise” before the Oct. 17 violence, which he blamed on “political and even seditious acts carried out by organized ultra-left groups whose aim is to bring down the Republic.”

Only union-organized demonstrations will be authorized on Saturday, on routes designed to protect shops and public buildings, he announced, and other gatherings will be banned “wherever we can.”

Read Entire Article