Labour Dominates This Year’s Mayoral Elections

The shock victory of Richard Parker in the West Midlands was the latest in Labour’s domination of this year’s mayoral elections.

Tory candidate Andy Street had hoped to cling on in the region, but the Labour challenger beat him with a majority of just 1,508 votes.

Speaking after the result was announced, Mr. Parker said that his election shows “people are calling for Labour, and calling for change.”

The Conservative loss was part of a double blow for Prime Minister Rishi Sunak after Labour’s Sadiq Khan secured a historic third term as Mayor of London.

Mr. Khan said “it’s time” for the prime minister to call a general election.

Labour notched up a string of wins by high-profile incumbents as well as scoring a clean sweep of victories in those parts of the country that were voting for a mayor for the first time.

Related Stories

In the East Midlands, Labour’s Claire Ward became the region’s first elected mayor with a majority of more than 50,000 votes over Tory Ben Bradley—who also sits as MP for Mansfield and leader of Nottinghamshire County Council.

Meanwhile, Labour’s Kim McGuinness won the new North East mayoral election with a majority of 58,399 over independent Jamie Driscoll.

And Labour’s David Skaith won the new York & North Yorkshire mayoral election—which includes the prime minister’s Richmond constituency—with a majority of almost 15,000 over the Conservatives.

A number of the re-elected Labour mayors took aim at the government or called for a general election after the result was announced.

In Liverpool, incumbent Steve Rotheram got 68 percent of the vote, then urged the prime minister to call a general election, saying “we are ready when you are.”

Andy Burnham speaks as he has been re-elected as Greater Manchester Mayor after winning 426,749 votes following the count at Manchester Central on May 4, 2024. (Peter Byrne/PA Wire)

Andy Burnham said Britain “desperately needs a new government and a fresh start” after he was re-elected as Greater Manchester Mayor with 63.4 percent of the vote.

Paul Dennett, who was re-elected as Salford City Mayor with 61.5 percent of the vote, said the “Westminster and Whitehall model” of governing was “clearly broken and detached from ordinary people’s lives.”

Labour’s Oliver Coppard retained his job as South Yorkshire Mayor with just over 50 percent of the vote and said he will “join millions of people across the north in calling out this government for their failure to level up our country”.

Labour’s Tracy Brabin retained her job as West Yorkshire Mayor after winning more than half of the votes.

In five of the 11 contests, Labour not only finished first but won more than 50 percent of the vote: This is no mean feat in elections held under the first-past-the-post system, where having multiple candidates on the ballot often means the winner does not end up with over half of the popular vote.

Indeed, this exact scenario happened in the five other mayoral contests won by Labour candidates: London (where Mr Khan got 43.8 percent of the vote), the North East (41.3 percent for Ms. McGuinness), East Midlands (40.3 percent for Ms. Ward), Birmingham (37.8 percent for Mr. Parker) and York & North Yorkshire (35.1 percent for Mr. Skaith).

Defeated Conservative Andy Street after Labour's Richard Parker is elected as the new Mayor of West Midlands, following the count at the International Convention Centre in Birmingham on May 4, 2024. (Jacob King/PA Wire)

Elections for the East Midlands, North East, and York & North Yorkshire mayors were being held for the first time, meaning there was no incumbency factor to boost the chances of a particular party.

They also took place in areas that will be key Conservative-Labour battlegrounds at the next general election—particularly the East Midlands which contains a high number of marginal seats.

Seen in this context, the sole Tory success in this year’s mayoral contests, the re-election of Ben Houchen in Tees Valley, is very much an outlier, though he did—like most of the other incumbents—manage to win more than half of the vote (53.6 percent).

Only three candidates stood in the Tees Valley contest—Conservative, Labour, and Liberal Democrat—which was the lowest number in any of this year’s mayoral elections.

Lord Houchen denied claims that he had sought to distance himself from Mr. Sunak during his campaign, saying: “People around here know I’m a Conservative.”